If nostr were the answer, people like me would be building on it.
Ask yourselves who the builders are that aren't choosing nostr, and why.
Then ask yourselves what all the people building here have in common.
Then compare these groups earnestly. I dont just mean Bitcoiners vs Bluehairsky. I mean their experience, talent, and reputation.
I mean the most talented and resourceful people; people that innovate, and have deep expertise. Why aren't they leaving where they are to build here?
Examples: Bitcoin Core devs, shitcoin expert devs that really do want to fix things, talented cryptographers, deeply experienced systems/p2p people, experienced entrepreneurs, reputable VCs and funders.
The closest I see here are people that got Bitcoin-rich and are now learning how to be angels by naively funding their friends and dead-end startup projects that arent much better than weekend hackathon submissions. A sandbox for playing.
Everything worth anything here is a subdivision of Bitcoin culture itself and Bitcoin privilege. Bitcoin is the only provider of talent and resources to Nostr. That worked great to bootstrap from nothing, but now what?
Deal with this, and figure out how to be relevant to other people, or Nostr will continue to be nothing more than a perpetual hackathon sandbox subsidized by a Bitcoiner ego-cult.
Thread
Login to reply
Replies (99)
As of now , most nostr devs here are learning what the Nostr protocol is - the focus is doing quick tutorials to gauge the limits of the protocol .. aka Twitter clone or Insta clones ..
I don't think anyone is claiming to replace X or Insta .. I mean ..if they do ..it is kinda pipe dream .. cuz users will always stick to time tested networks ... UNLESS ..they find a new value prop..
That said .. once the protocol becomes a default back end .. when you are NOT building for the protocol , but protocol is a default choice for the application you are focused on .. that is when the true innovation begins ... It is couple years in the future ... But I think we have the proof point for the protocol layer ... Nostr is new layer of internet .. If you are NOT learning /improving this protocol ..you are literally wasting your time ..
Holy shit. Blow yourself some more
I am sorry I hurt your protocol.
Keep going princess🤣🤣🤣🤣 everyone loves a stupid troll.
Experienced entrepreneurs aren’t here? Watch me motherfucker.
Show me something not retarded then.
You🫵🫵🫵🫵🫵🫵

Bookmarked for whenever I need motivation
…And one day to laugh at this stupid take
View quoted note →
I piss on your watermelons
We need #⭕👀 meme for this
He might be into that

one option is to build with us and fix what you don't like.
so simple...
Apparently it's too simple.
I will submit Pubky as a PR when we are done with it.
no one cares about it, no one will use it
Yeah but then he doesn't get to hand out invite codes.
no please, don't.
Im not sure i know the answer to the first 2 questions. But i would assume the answer would apply to any other decentralized platform...
So no one should work on any other decentralized social platform???!
Your protocol is doing the same mistake AP and Matrix and Bluesky and everyone else is doing
They aren’t building on nostr because they see more value building elsewhere. Whether that is true or not will become clear over time. But that is the simple answer.
They see more dollars* the value is in nostr. They just don't see it because time preference.
Only people raised on podcasts and bad books use the term "time preference" it is a clear red flag at this point.
@npub1kqx5...l3z8 proof of shitcoinery.
So time preference is not a real economic principle? Please argue that fact.
Only people trying to make competing protocols and stupid bips would make a post as short sighted as your own.
It's a clear red flag.
Zzzz
🤭🤭🤭🤭🫵🫵🫵🫵🫵🫣🫣🫣🫣😀😃😄😁😆😅😂🤣
Keep going this is great😂😂😂😂😂
You're not wrong — the strongest minds in systems, cryptography, and product aren’t here yet. But maybe that’s exactly the opportunity. Nostr isn’t about status. It’s about freedom. And most of the world’s best minds are still too busy surviving the fiat circus to notice what’s coming.
It is censorable, what freedom?
What free dumb he asks...🤣🤣🤣🫵🫵🫵🫵😅😅😅
You know onion relays? And even if we have to innovate beyond dns, we will if there's need to. It's not like all the events would get deleted and all the people would just shrug and go back to the gulag.
*bookmarked
Massive ego on this one
Grats on your tiny ego.
🤣
Bro I dig your post and your ego
I think more people should stay their intelligent arguments and opinions, whatever they may be
Haha cheers mate!
I'm a Nostr only nobody that digs it here, but this is a bad ass spoonful of "step up yo game" medicine - damn....
If nostr were the answer, people like me would be building on it.
Ask yourselves who the builders are that aren't choosing nostr, and why.
Then ask yourselves what all the people building here have in common.
Then compare these groups earnestly. I dont just mean Bitcoiners vs Bluehairsky. I mean their experience, talent, and reputation.
I mean the most talented and resourceful people; people that innovate, and have deep expertise. Why aren't they leaving where they are to build here?
Examples: Bitcoin Core devs, shitcoin expert devs that really do want to fix things, talented cryptographers, deeply experienced systems/p2p people, experienced entrepreneurs, reputable VCs and funders.
The closest I see here are people that got Bitcoin-rich and are now learning how to be angels by naively funding their friends and dead-end startup projects that arent much better than weekend hackathon submissions. A sandbox for playing.
Everything worth anything here is a subdivision of Bitcoin culture itself and Bitcoin privilege. Bitcoin is the only provider of talent and resources to Nostr. That worked great to bootstrap from nothing, but now what?
Deal with this, and figure out how to be relevant to other people, or Nostr will continue to be nothing more than a perpetual hackathon sandbox subsidized by a Bitcoiner ego-cult.
View quoted note →
Please let's get a podcast debate between John and some Nostr figure. The crowd wants to learn a lot more about the contrast between nostr and pubky.
Are there actual well-spoken mature and earnest people in nostr that can argue genuinely?
Or is this some sorta thing where i will have to refute a bunch of retarded memes?
😂😂😂😃😀🤣 your the only one not retarded... Please keep going.
Naw. I'm good. Aside from the memes, just ignore the guy.
no. we're all kids without age verification, drug dealers and money launderers.
lmao.... "bitcoin privilege"...
btw "experience, talent, and reputation" mean fuck all when it comes to recognizing the RIGHT thing to do, let alone ACTUALLY DOING IT.
most people are one-dimensional trained monkeybots with zero spiritual awareness and certainly no transcendental compass to guide their retarded and scientized intellect anywhere but toward money and quantity.
"figure out how to be relevant to other people".... LMAO who the fuck do you think you are you bag of dust?
Please smoke less weed
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 please keep going.
The gross (and delusional) elitism in yr 3rd paragraph is far too common in tech communities
whose 3rd paragraph? hard to tell haha
"Jews own everything" was such an alien word 2 years ago, and ever since that phrase started accumulating popularity a tendency toward low operation cost Apps has skyrocketed because it's the only way to guarantee zero Jewish influence
I'm here because of jews and most of new comers
If you can't address the reality around us then you can have fun staying politically correct any where other than nostr and get more reach, PUSSY.
If nostr were the answer, people like me would be building on it.
Ask yourselves who the builders are that aren't choosing nostr, and why.
Then ask yourselves what all the people building here have in common.
Then compare these groups earnestly. I dont just mean Bitcoiners vs Bluehairsky. I mean their experience, talent, and reputation.
I mean the most talented and resourceful people; people that innovate, and have deep expertise. Why aren't they leaving where they are to build here?
Examples: Bitcoin Core devs, shitcoin expert devs that really do want to fix things, talented cryptographers, deeply experienced systems/p2p people, experienced entrepreneurs, reputable VCs and funders.
The closest I see here are people that got Bitcoin-rich and are now learning how to be angels by naively funding their friends and dead-end startup projects that arent much better than weekend hackathon submissions. A sandbox for playing.
Everything worth anything here is a subdivision of Bitcoin culture itself and Bitcoin privilege. Bitcoin is the only provider of talent and resources to Nostr. That worked great to bootstrap from nothing, but now what?
Deal with this, and figure out how to be relevant to other people, or Nostr will continue to be nothing more than a perpetual hackathon sandbox subsidized by a Bitcoiner ego-cult.
View quoted note →
Lol "people like me". That ego is a seventh wonder.
I triggered you and now you have triggered nostr. I see you 👀
I hope you are right, but you haven't been yet. It will be interesting if you are.
We’re a little earlier for your logic to be correct
Let’s see in a few years when the guy in the street knows about Nostr
It's over guys. I'm moving @Zapstore to Pubky, the akshually open protocol that needs an invite code to create an account. After all, it's where the coolest p2p wizards, world-class entrepreneurs and VCs hang out.
I'm tired of being a nostr loser working this "freedom tech" nonsense bubble. Now is the time to become a shitcoin expert dev that really does want to fix things.
View quoted note →
🧂
If nostr were the answer, people like me would be building on it.
Ask yourselves who the builders are that aren't choosing nostr, and why.
Then ask yourselves what all the people building here have in common.
Then compare these groups earnestly. I dont just mean Bitcoiners vs Bluehairsky. I mean their experience, talent, and reputation.
I mean the most talented and resourceful people; people that innovate, and have deep expertise. Why aren't they leaving where they are to build here?
Examples: Bitcoin Core devs, shitcoin expert devs that really do want to fix things, talented cryptographers, deeply experienced systems/p2p people, experienced entrepreneurs, reputable VCs and funders.
The closest I see here are people that got Bitcoin-rich and are now learning how to be angels by naively funding their friends and dead-end startup projects that arent much better than weekend hackathon submissions. A sandbox for playing.
Everything worth anything here is a subdivision of Bitcoin culture itself and Bitcoin privilege. Bitcoin is the only provider of talent and resources to Nostr. That worked great to bootstrap from nothing, but now what?
Deal with this, and figure out how to be relevant to other people, or Nostr will continue to be nothing more than a perpetual hackathon sandbox subsidized by a Bitcoiner ego-cult.
View quoted note →
What a cringe post 😂 the people are temporary, the tech is forever. What a dumb critique. There are many people on nostr I don’t like either, but that doesn’t justify shit. Bitcoin is the money of enemies because its trust-minimized, so shall nostr be for communication.
stfu cuck
Ace job picking a name that was already in use by another brand but spelling it wrong to guarantee perpetual confusion.
I was wondering this too, if they were affiliated or if this was just dumb or malicious. I think the bar has a legal case.
When I was orange-pilling a friend, she said something like "they should make it easier to buy bitcoin."
With Nostr as with Bitcoin there is no they; there's only us.
If you think Nostr has potential, YOU figure out how to make it relevant to other people. In the meantime, we're all doing that in our own way here.
Projection? Maybe you're the ego-cult?
How many of us shitty devs have you tried to recruit into your invite only Rube Goldberg machine building ... "enterprise" without delivering a thing you dare to show publicly? You've been recruiting since at least two years.
I take this message of you as your farewell. Come back when you can show something.
BitTasker is not a company — it's a mission to decentralize income and make Bitcoin useful in everyday life.
Built on Nostr
#earnbtc #p2p #grownostr #decentralized
https://bittasker.com/
❤️🔥
If nostr were the answer, people like me would be building on it.
Ask yourselves who the builders are that aren't choosing nostr, and why.
Then ask yourselves what all the people building here have in common.
Then compare these groups earnestly. I dont just mean Bitcoiners vs Bluehairsky. I mean their experience, talent, and reputation.
I mean the most talented and resourceful people; people that innovate, and have deep expertise. Why aren't they leaving where they are to build here?
Examples: Bitcoin Core devs, shitcoin expert devs that really do want to fix things, talented cryptographers, deeply experienced systems/p2p people, experienced entrepreneurs, reputable VCs and funders.
The closest I see here are people that got Bitcoin-rich and are now learning how to be angels by naively funding their friends and dead-end startup projects that arent much better than weekend hackathon submissions. A sandbox for playing.
Everything worth anything here is a subdivision of Bitcoin culture itself and Bitcoin privilege. Bitcoin is the only provider of talent and resources to Nostr. That worked great to bootstrap from nothing, but now what?
Deal with this, and figure out how to be relevant to other people, or Nostr will continue to be nothing more than a perpetual hackathon sandbox subsidized by a Bitcoiner ego-cult.
View quoted note →
Nostr was started by lightning developers. Many of those devs are the most talented coders I know.
Lightning is still small, but mighty. So is nostr.
I've been following this on & off all day and I still fail to see what this guy is trying to accomplish here besides possibly poaching some developers or users? It comes across as very unprofessional.
All the points he's brought up have been discussed openly, with multiple ideas and proposals floated in a constructive, maybe sometimes contentious, fashion in the past. I have seen no reason to doubt the integrity of anyone who has chosen to take on the difficult tasks.
haters gonna hate
View quoted note →
"Ask yourself who the buikders are that aren't choosing nostr and why"
Immediately went to your pubky site and there is no link to your github (or even download via fdroid) so I could even possibly assess what are the benefits of the development you're doing without having google involved, so that is a red flag.
Uses aurora store, to download and immediately doesn't work without an invite code, red flag.
So what actually am I supposed to compare nostr to? Don't say centralized services either because sure having builders is cool, but most of those folks will admit to you that they are sacrificing some of their own principles because the pay is good. Like I guarantee you if you go ask engineers on Facebook about the fact that it's fucked up that no one outside fb can use the data they will agree.
This is the onboarding screen for your app 

I tried it too. I was not interested in accepting the pubky terms, did anyway, then the app could not connect to any servers and I closed it as useless
Compared to almost any actually permissionless Nostr app, this is … not working
BUT PEOPLE LIKE HIM WOULD BUILD ON NOSTR IF NOSTR WORKED, you know, if only we could all communicate easily via this protocol
John sounds like a shitcoiner trying to convince people to join his DAO
I love the minimalist design
clean, minimalist 🤙🏼
Such a boring and tired take from someone who doesn't build and doesn't ship products that people use.
This is the nostr version of getting ratiod.
54 replies with only 2 zaps (and 1 of the zaps is an ad 🤣)
John CarvalWho?
It’s kind of expected. Go to anyone’s house and start dunking on it and the people inside.
What is ironic is that he’s here and we are not on whatever it is he is building 😌 he mad
I think you're butthurt the DID idea didnt pan out and nostr is winning.
"I tried to build a walled garden but nostr took all my potential users so I am going to complain about nostr on nostr"
View quoted note →
I opened this thread incognito to see how many responses came from people I have muted.
Most of them! Oof.
If you want a response, try X? I probably have you muted there too though...
View quoted note →
1. Nostr doesn't need people like you. Ego is not a skill set that pervades Nostr. This is not Twitter.
2. First impressions from your statement- predatory, monetizing and attempts to undermine the vibrant culture growing from the roots up. Not from the tree tops down.
3. Take the time to check out Jack Dorsey, Jeff Booth, Lyn Alden - all of them and many others like them are here educating dumb asses like me, and I'm grateful.
4. So get down from that tree top and stop Godomizing yourself .
People like you? Who do you think you are mate? Little advice: you’re not as relevant as you think you are. Might wanna check your ego at the door.
Bitcoin is succeeding because centralized FIAT failed.
Nostr will succeed when centralized social medias fail. It just needs to be ready when the time comes.
To answer your question. You have a very centralized way to think. I don't believe that a good idea is automatically adopted by everyone.
The reason @npub13ndp...0svh hates Nostr is because he's being paid by Tether to develop a competing project. Simple as that.
The same goes for the rest of the Twitter influencers, the reason they all hate Nostr is because they're being paid by Elon.
If nostr were the answer, people like me would be building on it.
Ask yourselves who the builders are that aren't choosing nostr, and why.
Then ask yourselves what all the people building here have in common.
Then compare these groups earnestly. I dont just mean Bitcoiners vs Bluehairsky. I mean their experience, talent, and reputation.
I mean the most talented and resourceful people; people that innovate, and have deep expertise. Why aren't they leaving where they are to build here?
Examples: Bitcoin Core devs, shitcoin expert devs that really do want to fix things, talented cryptographers, deeply experienced systems/p2p people, experienced entrepreneurs, reputable VCs and funders.
The closest I see here are people that got Bitcoin-rich and are now learning how to be angels by naively funding their friends and dead-end startup projects that arent much better than weekend hackathon submissions. A sandbox for playing.
Everything worth anything here is a subdivision of Bitcoin culture itself and Bitcoin privilege. Bitcoin is the only provider of talent and resources to Nostr. That worked great to bootstrap from nothing, but now what?
Deal with this, and figure out how to be relevant to other people, or Nostr will continue to be nothing more than a perpetual hackathon sandbox subsidized by a Bitcoiner ego-cult.
View quoted note →
My boy John always knows how to schmooze 😂😂
View quoted note →
Maybe “NOSTR sucks” because you have everyone muted.
Probably right about this
I think you're right about Nostr as a social media platform, but if nothing else, Nostr has made my remote node way more usable because of NWC. That is a win
😄 Terms of Service
😂 Privacy Policy
🤣 Age Verification


If nostr were the answer, people like me would be building on it.
Ask yourselves who the builders are that aren't choosing nostr, and why.
Then ask yourselves what all the people building here have in common.
Then compare these groups earnestly. I dont just mean Bitcoiners vs Bluehairsky. I mean their experience, talent, and reputation.
I mean the most talented and resourceful people; people that innovate, and have deep expertise. Why aren't they leaving where they are to build here?
Examples: Bitcoin Core devs, shitcoin expert devs that really do want to fix things, talented cryptographers, deeply experienced systems/p2p people, experienced entrepreneurs, reputable VCs and funders.
The closest I see here are people that got Bitcoin-rich and are now learning how to be angels by naively funding their friends and dead-end startup projects that arent much better than weekend hackathon submissions. A sandbox for playing.
Everything worth anything here is a subdivision of Bitcoin culture itself and Bitcoin privilege. Bitcoin is the only provider of talent and resources to Nostr. That worked great to bootstrap from nothing, but now what?
Deal with this, and figure out how to be relevant to other people, or Nostr will continue to be nothing more than a perpetual hackathon sandbox subsidized by a Bitcoiner ego-cult.
View quoted note →
So busy building yet took the time to embarrass himself publicly. That’s cute.
View quoted note →
Stop being a faggot
People look to justify their own actions all the time
“People like me” says it all
You’re free to build wherever you want John, that’s absolutely true
Go for it
I hope you’re not missing ways to potentially incorporate Nostr into your products as they are
As for the potential of Nostr, let’s see with time what’s true
I for one embrace the idea that a new generation of capital allocators are entering the fray, backing ideas they see as valuable, in a manner that makes sense to them
If wrong. The time and moneys gone. If right. Well you’re point is totally disproven
I don't know anyone using pubky.
"Bitcoin privilege" 🤣 😂
This note is an exercise in performative contradiction.