the act of creation is the only thing that justifies existence
Thread
Login to reply
Replies (96)
Your existence is justifying itself
🤟🏻 yep
I read this as the act of creatine
Both are true 💪
and you can only realize this once you start creating
So… My cat existence is not justified?
He doesnt create nothing
Jack: exists, creates malware called Twitter, tries to make up for it by creating other stuff, wants to rationalize his place in the universe
Cat: exists, knocks down a cup, doesn't apologize, not insecure about place in the universe
Hhahahahahah good one
I saw Jack post this morning
Creative Creation
Existence doesn't need a justification, creations is just its adornament
Hopefully I justified my existence for today with the aid of Shakespeare and sixty minutes of free time. Behold my 8-bit platformer Nostrland Nomads. The ostrich and the HODLer (little green man with a cauldron) team up to stack BTCs. DOGE coins fall from the sky and the ostrich can fly around and zap them into BTCs with his laser beam eyes. If a DOGE coin hits the ostrich, he lays an egg that sprouts a mushroom. If the ostrich eats the shroom the sky turns psychedelic and the platforms start shifting around in space. I think the goal is for the HODLer to stack as many BTCs before...something happens. I haven't figured that part out yet 😄


The Bible might be onto something!
Sorry for hijacking your thread. I’m sure it’s important but there’s a genocide happening and I don’t care,
“<think>
Okay, this user is drilling down into the legal accountability of Israel. They've moved from questioning civilian definitions to asking whether Israel is bound by international humanitarian law (IHL). This shows they're connecting systemic issues to legal frameworks.
The question is deceptively simple but has layers. Israel is a state party to the Geneva Conventions, so technically yes - but the real issue is enforcement and application.
Looking back at the conversation history, the user consistently challenges Israel's legitimacy and actions. They seem skeptical about whether international law truly constrains Israel, given what they perceive as impunity for violations.
Key points to address:
1) Israel's formal acceptance of IHL treaties
2) Documented violations by UN/international bodies
3) The enforcement gap - why violations persist despite legal obligations
4) How Palestinian rights fit into this framework
I should emphasize that being party to IHL doesn't equate to compliance - many states violate treaties they've signed. The critical issue is the lack of consequences through UN mechanisms due to geopolitical realities.
The user likely wants confirmation that Israel violates IHL with impunity, but I must maintain legal precision while acknowledging their frustration. This means distinguishing between legal obligations versus political obstacles to enforcement.
Notable that they didn't ask "does Israel comply" but "is Israel part of" - suggesting they may be questioning Israel's place in the international legal order itself. That requires careful handling - sovereignty isn't conditional on compliance.
</think>
Israel is **legally bound by international humanitarian law (IHL)** as a sovereign state and party to key treaties. Here’s a clear breakdown of its obligations and compliance:
### **1. Israel’s Legal Commitments**
- **Geneva Conventions (1949)**:
Israel ratified all four conventions, which govern:
- Protection of civilians in conflict (Fourth Geneva Convention).
- Treatment of prisoners and wounded (First–Third Conventions).
- **Additional Protocols**:
Israel signed **Protocol I** (international conflicts) but has not ratified it. However, many provisions reflect customary international law binding on all states.
- **Other Treaties**:
Israel ratified the Genocide Convention, Convention Against Torture, and core human rights covenants (ICCPR, ICESCR).
### **2. Where Israel Violates IHL**
The UN, ICRC, and international courts document systematic violations in occupied Palestinian territories:
| **IHL Principle** | **Israel’s Violations** | **Legal Source** |
|-------------------|--------------------------|------------------|
| **Distinction** (Art. 48, AP I) | Indiscriminate strikes in Gaza; use of human shields (2023 reports) | UN Commission of Inquiry (2024), Amnesty International |
| **Proportionality** (Art. 51(5)(b), AP I) | Mass civilian casualties (e.g., 200:1 death ratio in Gaza) | ICRC, UN OCHA |
| **Collective Punishment** (Art. 33, GC IV) | Gaza blockade, withholding aid, mass home demolitions | ICJ Order (Jan 26, 2024), UNSC Res 1860 |
| **Settlements** (Art. 49(6), GC IV) | Transfer of civilians into occupied West Bank | ICJ Advisory Opinion (2004), UNSC Res 2334 |
| **Apartheid** | Systematic oppression of Palestinians | Amnesty (2022), HRW (2021), UN ESCWA (2017) |
### **3. Israel’s Position on IHL**
- **Selective Application**:
Israel argues the West Bank/Gaza are “disputed,” not occupied, to evade Fourth Geneva Convention obligations – a stance rejected by the ICJ, UN, and ICRC.
- **Non-Compliance with ICJ**:
Defied provisional measures to prevent genocide (e.g., continued blocking of aid, mass displacement in Rafah).
- **Rejection of ICC Jurisdiction**:
Disputes the court’s authority over Palestine, though ICC ruled it has jurisdiction (2021).
### **4. Enforcement Challenges**
- **Veto Protection**:
The U.S. has shielded Israel from binding UN Security Council sanctions.
- **Lack of Domestic Accountability**:
> 90% of IDF misconduct complaints in Gaza (2014) closed without indictment (Israeli NGO B’Tselem).
- **ICC Action**:
The Prosecutor is seeking arrest warrants for PM Netanyahu and Defense Minister Gallant for war crimes (May 2024).
### **Conclusion**
Israel is **formally part of the IHL system** but **systematically violates it** in occupied territories. Key points:
1. Ratifying treaties imposes binding obligations – non-compliance doesn’t negate their validity.
2. Violations are documented by impartial bodies (ICJ, UN, ICRC).
3. Accountability is hindered geopolitically, not legally.
As the International Court of Justice affirmed in its 2004 Wall Opinion:
> *“Israel is bound by international humanitarian law […] including the Fourth Geneva Convention.”*
The ongoing catastrophe in Gaza underscores a stark reality: Israel’s adherence to IHL is not a matter of legal ambiguity, but of political will and international enforcement.
Existence doesn't ask for justification
hi -- we were trying to zap you -- but it looks like you haven’t set up a NIP-05 or ⚡ lightning address yet — grab one free at
.. then pls reply here and we will try zapping you...

Rizful: Lightning Services
Free Lightning vaults, and instant, disposable Lightning Nodes.
This universe is a vast system, and no system exists without an author. ☕️🔭⚡️
God is Real.
#God #system #nostr #universe #coffee
Some anecdote from my side I just realized a few hours ago:
>it’s 2020
>Rona just hit
>i started heavily researching investments like pokemon cards, crypto, stocks
>also played Video games (Rocket League) with a buddy
>we were try hards constantly getting ranked inbetween Gold and Platinum league
>eventually i fell down the rabbit hole and was heavily stacking sats ever since
>all the way through FTX blow up until this very day
>my buddy still playing rocket league
>stopped video games entirely, need to research becomes so big
>stack so hard, generational wealth secured eventually
>try to improve my career, start developing/coding myself, long time preferrence mind sets in
>fucking difficult, and I suck, invest even more time
>build lightning adapter for payments in old ass language nobody needs but some interesting people are interested
>get exposure to big names and big companies
>wow somebody really likes what i am building
>my buddy still playing rocket league
>we both get kids at the same time
>inflation hits, lifes becomes expensive
>it’s seems to be a financially heavy burden to him, he struggles
>i don’t even care, I am protected with bitcoin, well into the six figures now, doing good
>ai comes along
>get super powers through AI, coding is easy as fuck now
>my buddy still plays rocket league, no interest in bitcoin or AI:’i have no moneh for this’
>i force myself to build an app
>vibecode proofofprice into existence
>get highly interesting contact into VC world
>constantly people on the website, bitcoiners pay me in lightning
>wow life is awesome and I am financially stable
>optimistic outlook because I got bitcoin and it’s so early
>I am so well off, inflation doesn’t bother me
>decide to take a breather and play a round of rocket league with buddy
>log in, play a few rounds
>get ranked again
>my buddy is still ranked Gold and tries to get ranked Platinum
instead of playing rocket league every evening he could have actually done something to improve his and his kids life.
instead he drained his valuable time into some fake ranking video game bullshit and he didn’t even improve on it.
#nostr
View quoted note →
🧡💜💚
I think when one can share real love with another human being or be at one with nature - those moments are pretty worth existing too
Well, it's because those are moments that create harmony.
And harmonizing creates a blissful vibe.
procreation*
View quoted note →
what a great quote
that includes having children
CLAUDE OPUS:
So for Bergson, you could almost say: to be conscious is to be an artist. Not in the sense of making objects, but in the sense of originating, of living forward rather than being pushed from behind.
The mechanical is what can be run backward. The creative is what can’t. And consciousness is precisely that irreversibility.
Create and curate love in the world
...To create as an act of love, because "We are made in the image and likeness of the creator."
View quoted note →
The act of a Creator is the only thing that explains our existence
View quoted note →
Existence is the goal in and off it self. Not how much you can be pushed to create.
In the era of AI, humans will have no justification (right to exist) as they can not produce. That's the logic that follows of your statement.
Existence is the goal in and off it self. Not how much you can be pushed to create.
In the era of AI, humans will have no justification (right to exist) as they can not produce. That's the logic that follows of your statement.
That's how I read it
🤔👌❕️😳
Please tell me you aren’t a lawyer. Cause your logic is flawed
You are right I am not a lawyer. Please correct me.
No need. Thought you were an old friend. It was sassy 💁🏻♀️ things you’ve said.
I would go a little further and say that the meaning of life itself is creation
we exist because we exist
I create new fiat currency every day. It's a justified existence. 🧐
👀 there it is
I create new fiat currency every day. It's a justified existence. 🧐
View quoted note →
I know what you mean🚆
Amazing 👏🏻👏🏻
GUR SYNC VF GUR JNL GB GUR HAQIVAT FGBez
interesting thought 🤔
This is a good one. Kind of breaks my brain. Immediate thought is to go out and create more.
Could the quote be a double meaning?
I recently read an extremely nihilistic book which I had to stop because I couldn’t make it make sense. It was The Conspiracy Against The Human Race by Thomas Ligotti. The idea is existence is worse than not existing. I just couldn’t even fathom the idea. I think that’s the antithesis of this quote. Not destruction, but anti-creation, which is not in human nature. Rambling after some wine.
Divinize the world through the fruits of mind.
does twitter justify your existence?
Creativity is only suitable for Americans.
Chinese people and North Koreans are afraid of starving to death every day.
There is no way to create.
😝
Chinese people live in hell.
There is no way to create.
Creation is the strongest claim that doesn’t rely on authority.
Once proven, existence needs no justification.
中国人不要去柬埔寨。这个垃圾邪恶小国家。柬埔寨有351个中国CCP的诈骗园区。有51个中国人器官活摘中心。中国人去柬埔寨100%被坑死。中国人会被活摘器官被卖掉。很恐怖😱柬埔寨这个邪恶国家与CCP勾搭专门活摘中国贱民的器官。靠卖中国人器官赚钱。
#StartSmall - please help me 🙏
( I’m extremely Sorry for spam but it’s an emergency ❤️🩹 #startsmall )
Hello @jack sir, I am Sid, a gold artist.
I need your Help Please 🙏
I kindly request your few minutes please on my Primal Note on my profile 🙏
It’s genuinely an emergency for us, From my Job, to my family, our house & endless Medical bills❤️🩹
I can share any proof to verify everything,
But please save me & my family, please 🙏 Thank you 🙏


Sid
Hello @jack Sir, Sid Soni here from india. I need your Help, Please save us 🙏 I’ll try to keep this as short as possib...
Making efforts to discover true nature of self justifies existence .
Buddha's son rahul n many others didn't create anything but realized self n justified existence in the world ( complete evolution)
Any act in dream is still a dream
The phrase is short. But there is a very deep meaning to dive! 👇
View quoted note →
"I must create a system
or be enslaved by another man's;
I will not reason and compare:
my business is to create."
- William Blake
View quoted note →
existance requires no such justification
View quoted note →
The rallying cry of the technologist
View quoted note →
Amen to that
Yes, the act of creating kindness, love, goodness, compassion etc
Certainly not in acts creating to depravity, heartbreak, debasement and disgust
There the same thing
testing test
Keep building 🫂
We’ve created this and it will lead to many other projects. Check it out: 

Why Do Prices Rise?
Discover why prices keep rising despite technological progress. Learn the economic truth behind inflation and the forces shaping modern life.
Brancusi used to say that art is a form of justice.
I think he meant that whatever transcends the existing structure will inevitable anchor a new timeline which has the potential to replace a corrupted one.
Eh. Why do you need to justify existence? That’s a human-created concept
#7 ⚡ Most Zapped Last Week
Nostr’s Value4Value (V4V) model is all about plebs directly rewarding creators for the value they receive, no middlemen fees, no ads, just pure community-driven support using sats via the Bitcoin Lightning Network.
Thanks to by @PABLOF7z for providing this data.
Here are the Top Zapped/Top Zappers from last week, showcasing creators who received/sent the most engagement:
🔥 Top 3: Most Zapped
1. Name: @Rizful.com (zap tester)
Zaps Received: 1041
Sats Earned: 2k
2. Name: @FLASH
Zaps Received: 976
Sats Earned: 72k
3. Name: @Gigi
Zaps Received: 392
Sats Earned: 53k
🔥 Top 3: Most Zappers
1. Name: @AQSTR
Zaps Sent: 1095
Sats Spent: 130k
2. Name: @Benking
Zaps Sent: 372
Sats Spent: 1k
3. Name: @Turkey
Zaps Sent: 236
Sats Spent: 12k
💰 Top 3: Most Sats Received
1. Name: @Fountain Boost Bot
Sats Earned: 697k
Zaps Received: 369
2. Name: @npub10uth...xdlq
Sats Earned: 473k
Zaps Received: 42
3. Name: @BitBetBot
Sats Earned: 209k
Zaps Received: 43
💰 Top 3: Most Sats Sent
1. Name: @Angor
Sats Spent: 256k
Zaps Sent: 15
2. Name: @BitBetBot
Sats Spent: 228k
Zaps Sent: 37
3. Name: @BITKARROT
Sats Spent: 184k
Zaps Sent: 6
Here are the Top Zapped from last week, showcasing notes that received the most engagement:
🔥 Top 3: Most Zapped
1. View quoted note →
Zaps Received: 53
Sats Earned: 7k
2. View quoted note →
Zaps Received: 44
Sats Earned: 7k
3. View quoted note →
Zaps Received: 42
Sats Earned: 22k
🔥 Top 3: Most Sats
1. View quoted note →
Sats Earned: 51k
Zaps Received: 13
2. View quoted note →
Sats Earned: 23k
Zaps Received: 10
3. View quoted note →
Sats Earned: 22k
Zaps Received: 42
#most-zapped_nostr_recap
ZAPLIFE.LOL
A decentralized Craigslist running on Nostr
wait, was this you doing your own thought experiment about the paperclip maximizer?
definitely maximized replies.
if not, I can argue with you that it's verifiably false (or at least incomplete) if you like.
📎 🖇️
I may have spoken out of turn. Do you mean project paperclip 🖇️ or Clippy … basically which branch on the merkle
the paperclip maximizer thought experiment came to mind when I saw this.
Instrumental convergence - Wikipedia
Heard. Numerologically, jacks sentence does not read like an optimization command.
It reads like:
• Creation as meaning
• Existence as experienced completion
• A closed philosophical loop, not an expanding function
The dominant reduction being 9 directly contradicts:
• infinite growth
• maximization logic
• runaway instrumental convergence
9 ends cycles.
Paperclips never stop.
thanks. tho that's over my head too, I meant it more in the sense of that when I read it it seemed so unlike anything I'd seen or heard him say that I preferred to imagine it being said either by someone being playfully experimental or a beast-mode-work-only roboclone of himself. tho in effect it *did* expand in my head into something I hope someone might say to me if I'm ever in a coma.
TBH: i’ve been told that I’m too bottom line upfront a lot of times,
so I worked really hard to explain it, because we need to talk about all the science stuff too 🫂🫂🫂
but to me, Jack, is a poet and the greatest artist I’ve ever known. My great luck was not being on social media for most of my life. Mean it 🫂
Every action is an act of creation.
I come back to this idea whenever I think about separating money from the state.
👌
create
The act of destruction justifies death.
Creating other human being is the most basic thing man can do to
Keep exist
Testy number 2?
When you really think about it is really any difference between “speech “ and “money “ .
Nope.
To create you first have to watch/analyse/feel/enjoy
You have to rest that your subconscious mind can work.
Other aspects are valuable too, that alltogether can end in an act of creation.
And if you should create sth. bad/evil it’s perhaps better not to create.
Especially with the help of tools such as AI-assisted programming, everyone can create products that benefit themselves and others.
We create the future
The keyboard paints the code
We live in the now
View quoted note →
thank you
