Thread
You can't be both anti censorship and pro soft fork
Soft forks *are* censorship
For example, if you soft fork in CTV via modifying the behavior of an OP_SUCCESS opcode (as I'd like to do) you necessarily censor transactions that try to use OP_SUCCESS the old way
Replies (2)
BIP 119 says it changes OP_NOP4, why modify OP_SUCCESS instead?
It's like changing the meaning of a word in a dictionary. Some might use the old dictionary still, but if the majority are using the newest edition, then they won't understand the meaning of those who are using the word in the old sense. Maybe that's censorship. George Orwell seemed to imply it was.
