Thread

Like with Zap store only one that has web based apps and things too.

both hivetalk and corny chat were removed after it left Karnage

That's weird

Apparently they aren't "Legit Nostr" apps but where listed when Karnage ran it.

Maybe I'm not a Legit Dev?

What sucks is that it isn’t the go-to curated apps list nostrapps gets shouted out in every nostr guide

Yup, it’s my go-to tho. All we can do is our part. 🫡

I’ll make sure I constantly push it

LFG

it’s the go-to curated list of apps why would i or anyone else make one when there’s gonna be one that constantly gets pushed in front of new users? literally in every nostr guide think logically here, @fiatjaf shouldn’t be the sole dictator of what gets added or removed from that curated list which EVERYONE is using to help onboard users why doesn’t he just allow people to submit them and also sign them giving them a trust score of some sort?? there has to be a better way with the already existing go-to curated list of apps

Isn't there a wiki nip out there? Maybe a nostr native wiki page fixes this?

so that fixes all the already existing n constantly used nostr guides with nostrapps in them? cool cool

It does if the nostrapps redirects or includes a link 🤷‍♂️ what has @fiatjaf said about your concerns?

That would never happen he doesn’t reply to my concerns only my shitposts

what if he’s here today n gone tomorrow?

that's not true, even if it were it wouldn't matter, the nips repo is FAR less important than people think

It's much more important and a hindrance to innovation, as well as basically forcing us all to use GitHub.

why is it the nips repo a hindrance to innovation?

Because it gives the repo managers an easy way to diss other people's projects and demoralize new builders.

the nips repo matters for documentation. if half the nips dont merge, that sucks for discoverability. youre saying they dont matter in one sense, but you gotta think of the countless devs ive sent a nip draft spec they cant find.

Just publish it somewhere else? I don’t even publish all my nips there

if it bothered me enough, i would 😁 maintainership is a lotta work. maybe someone will someday ⚡

why? you can literally just publish it as a wiki event; it doesn't need to be a piece of a bigger thing like: https://wikifreedia.xyz/onion-routing-nip/f7z.io

crazy, & @Wavlake isn’t even on it either

Many don’t before @fiatjaf taking over @Karnage designed it all & also added new ones based on recommendations by plebs, which is great bc plebs are the users.

This is wwhat I remembered and was shilling it because/thanks to him posting about it. Great work of design, so neat. So I am reading there's more than one of those list/sources. What are they? 🫂

This is the legit by plebs for plebs list

Awesome Nostr Resources

A comprehensive collection of Nostr resources, tools, clients, and protocols for developers and users.

Thanks, bookmarked. 🫂🤙🏼

He removed relaytools, Hivetalk and Cornychat and also hasn’t added Wavlake

Wtf? I can see not wavlake but not the others They're nostr native

Yup also I think Wavlake belongs there bc you can post notes from it n also use your nostr identity same with fountain which also has a nostr feed for RSS related content using your social graph this is just coming from the idea of allowing people to fully experience the diverse nostr ecosystem, not just whatever one person deems to be a nostr app

Oh I did not know that. Very cool BTW how are you putting your music on there? RSS feed?

Uploading through @Wavlake they literally distribute it for you & it shows up everywhere else it’s a no brainer

They do. They create and host your RSS feed for you. They charge 10% of your earned sats for the service. But it’s just an RSS feed, nothing special.

Dope I'll look into it Shows up on fountain too?

Yeah!

Fountain

Fountain

Discover millions of podcasts and emerging artists worth supporting. Powered by RSS, Lightning and Nostr.

OK gotta try

Also, the reason it's good is because it's curated — which is most easily accomplished by centralization. Someday nostrapp.link will be better but... it's not

Want me to be completely honest? Reason why it’s good or was good is bc @Karnage designed it, and also allowed for outsiders to request apps to be added, I requested 6 months ago for him to take a look at Hivetalk for him to add n he did take a look n added it..

His design is good. Have you talked to fiatjaf about this?

i believe I raised concerns when it was first handed off, but not as of recently, I’ve seen people discussing it but never heard from him about this. Im also curious what he will do

fiatjaf is not a reasonable human being. he operates in gfy. its why he can think outside the box so well. he says gfy to the box. and subsequently most other people. plan navigation accordingly

gfy is gfy

Yeah, I build a bad ass website that’s run on port 80? Am I not welcome in the nostr ecosystem? I

me proud asf on the sidelines like

Please put @Wavlake on it!

This is fantastic.

LETS GOO!!!

It's awesome(pun intended).

LFG 🥕

I can’t believe nostr.build isn’t on that list tbh

There’s a list? 🤣

🤣🤣🤣 yessss & it would be useful for users to come across your platform when they search what they think is our full ecosystem of nostr apps

What makes something a nostr app? If I simply allow sign in with an nsec is it a nostr app? What is the minimum criteria?

Whatever @fiatjaf comes up with when he wakes up tomorrow

If you were the King of nostr, what would your minimum criteria be?

at least the use of one NIP and nsec sign in

What about you?

I haven’t been around long enough to understand nostr and have much of an opinion on what makes something a nostr app From my limited understanding, it seems if you’re sending and/or receiving signed events to/from a relay, you’re a nostr app.

maybe that and log in could be good enough minimum criteria as you continue to build it out or maybe don’t have the need to add anything else n minimum criteria is where it resides n that’s fine if that’s all it needs to use n it solves its purpose n is useful

A little push back on even the sign in. Do you remember a site called Postcard or something, where you could anonymously confess something for the whole internet to read by sending in a postcard and they would put it on their site? If I had an app that let people anonymously write their confession, then created a signed event using the nsec for the confess-bot account anyone could follow, then sent the event to relays, would that be a nostr app?