if it is not obvious yet the game is gold vs bitcoin
competing monies, one will win
my bet is on bitcoin, all in
Thread
Login to reply
Replies (56)
its funny, because for a moment I thought we were fighting on the same sides.
The power if our enemy is successfully sowing division. Which it does. Apparently, quite successfully.
Gold and bitcoin are on the same side. Honest money versus counterfeit money. Private money versus government money.
It's not a contest, they both have their uses. But gold is more robust.
That might be the ultimate game, but the way bitcoin wins isn't by competing with gold; it's by competing with visa/mastercard. (et al) Once bitcoin has won that battle, it will have become the de facto king of Store of Value as well.
Said another way: I believe bitcoin has already demonstrated it can co-exist with gold as Stores of Value. Neither money will have defeated the other until it manages to also become a ubiquitous payment network.
I appreciate the self reassuring echo chamber that is Nostr when it comes to BTC and you may well be right. But when it comes to life savings, why not have both in meaningful amounts. I mean how rich do you want to be when you die anywayβ¦..
And you sleep better => Live longer π
We can each buy what we wish. I don't expect to go to the store and buy groceries with a gold bar, but I do expect to be able to pay with Bitcoin. So, I know what I'm buying.
True.
But the 1 BTC = goldbar, sats are gold coins.
However you are right, gold is clunky.
There will always be more gold to find, to dig up, or to gather from asteroids and other worlds. There will only ever be 21 million Bitcoin.
When you see gold as analog bitcoin, it begins to make sense.
Bitcoin has already won against gold.
There can be multiple monies. Gold or silver in person and bitcoin online.
Bro zoom out. Look at the 100 year silver graph. Why would you hold an inferior asset. It's a winner take all game.
Zoom out further. Look at the 1000 year history.
The good attributes of bitcoin rest on a foundation of social agreement. The good attributes of gold and silver rest on a foundation of nature.
Time and energy verified is the most natural foundation. Silver vs gold already played out. Gold failed when paper money was created. Bitcoin is now naturally winning. Slowly then suddenly.
Bitcoin is being coopted by the same forces that coopted gold and silver. Custodians, higher layers, ETFs, KYC/AML, treated like a stock for tax purposes, etc. That's essentially "paper bitcoin." All the same stuff that disabled gold and silver as money have happened or are happening.
We say "not your keys, not your bitcoin" and that's correct. By the same logic we can say "not cold hard cash in your hand, not your gold or silver."
Have you tried using bitcoin as money recently? It works great in a few cases but is far more tedious to use than in its heyday.
It has been a while since I used gold and silver as money. It also works great in a few cases but is also far more tedious to use than in its heyday.
I don't have to be anti-gold or anti-silver to be pro-bitcoin and neither does anyone else. We are on the same team. The goal is to get governments out of the money business entirely.
Would you revive silver as payment? I wouldnβt want to receive either. Seems kinda hard to get bitcoin out of it. Fiat is great for that. I can self custody bitcoin and verify it easy. Running a node is easy. Bitcoin is much more easy for me.
I happily receive silver, gold, and bitcoin as payment.
I understand your point we are 2 different people in the free market here
Same, but I do think we will go thru a period of bimetalism
my bet is on brass, bitcoin, booze, tampons, nicotine, venison and toilet paper
Nicotine brother!
Two questions end this debate:
1. What institution demonetized gold? Central banks
2. Who is driving the gold bull market? Central banks
How many times can people fall for the same rug pull?
Yeah and for me the strategy looks pretty simple. Trump administration waits for full gold remonetization, revalues balance sheet, gets 1T in liquidity, buys 100 billion Bitcoin, further monetizing Bitcoin.
Why would the US want to monetize gold again, when BRICS are hoarding gold. It makes zero financial sense. The play would be to monetize Bitcoin and have Saylor go around the world to create the seeds of the new T-bill, Bitbond.
Apart from this there will be the AI bubble risk capital moving from AI to the next risk asset. They'll certainly not play gold.
Unfortunately, they donβt have to buy the Bitcoin. They control upstream energy resources and can βacquire/investβ downstream βstrategically importantβ companies like Strategy. In the end, a Treasury Dept eager to acquire Bitcoin will defeat the Fed, I just hope they donβt destroy property rights to do it.
Yeah, I get that. By the way, so you think the Treasury Department will not acquire Bitcoin?
I think theyβll seize it and mine it in secret. Hash rate is no longer sensitive to price and energy costs are going up so they may already be mining it. Bessent slipped when he said they were only going seize Bitcoin not buy it. He walked that back but and went with the βtax-neutralβ official talking point. I think theyβll seize sovereign wealth fund may acquire more than the treasury.
Ah, good point. Mining would perfectly fit the situation, with the whole "drill baby drill" energy thing.
Lindy effect vs technical superiority.
Old vs new.
Limited supply vs hard cap.
damn, gold is beating the shit out of bitcoin if we think about that:


how much gold is there? You'd need that number to calculate the market cap, wouldn't you?
This year yes
My gold node cant verify sorry!! You will need to trust them!!
Why do we need only one? The world is much better and stronger with many different forms of sound moneyβ¦ We (as a spices) should newer aim for one thing that solves everythingβ¦ Many good options strengthens decentralisationβ¦
This ^^^^
Problem with gold is that it's not exactly easy to trust its form... either digitally or physically.
Best takes all. That how it works.
Why would you diverse in to something that isn't the best?
The gold people have way more capital. They have very short time and nothing new to create.
Also remember 10T is paper gold... Which is almost half of all gold. It's not trivial.
Let me see you make something IRL with zeros & ones...
The other is an actually useful element that is rare.
Energy is literally life bro lol
Catch phrases? Really...
Time + energy
So I'm actually better off walking outside, bumping off that animal, cooking it & eating it & saving myself the time with an intermediary, got it. π
Proof of work!
Gold failed when paper money was created! Lol
I'm not a trader, but I've been wondering if that 80k Bitcoin sale was done to keep us from breaking out against gold
We were about to break the ath and had momentum
Will anyone change their tune if we go below the btc/gold 2017 peak? 8 year flat vs gold out of 16, would make all the real gains in 2009-2017 and flat from 2017-2025.
many already are
True I guess I miss a lot because Iβm only on here so I donβt know what ppl are saying on X.
What he said!π§β‘οΈπ§
View quoted note β
no
it is monero against NPCs
Let's further slow the Bitcoin/Gold ratio by letting everyone know non-monetary data is welcome on Bitcoin's blockchain. Let's completely nuke the 80-byte default and change it to, I don't know, how about 0.1 MB? This will make gold stronger against Bitcoin.
Oh wait...
Bitcoin has been losing to gold this entire year.
Nobody buys a cup of coffee with gold