there is a large moneyary investment in this space in centralized nostr (primal) and centralized bitcoin (cashu)
Criticizing any of these? Good luck getting a grant or invited to that next prestigious event.
nostr was more fun when it wasnβt being subverted by money and influence peddling.
Unfortunately they canβt buy me or shut me up. I couldnβt give more of a shit about money or influence.
Thread
Login to reply
Replies (64)
π«
Solution: Invite more FOSS devs who donβt give a ratβs ass about grants or BTC/Nostr conferences. Fat Zap them so they actually keep building their stuff.
Hint: Remember that most folks capable of building solutions on Nostr or BTC/Lightning could easily be earning around US$1k a day as contractors, (depending on where they live of course).
this is true
Those zaps would need to be bigger than most of the grants.
They should. Folks here are fighting for pennies. I mean, honestly, even in Germany, where salaries are relatively lower than in the US, how much would a Senior QA person like you earn? Around β¬100k a year base, at least in Berlin or Munich? And youβre going way, way, way beyond quality and testing here on Nostr. Plus, you have other people working with you.
So I donβt see why anyone would expect something as ambitious as, say, Alexandria to get off the ground purely with grant money as, even in this awful market of ours. We need to move beyond the amateur Web3 full-stack TypeScript/Deno "vibecoder on a shoestring budget" phase before we can even start talking seriously about V2V on Nostr. Other than for maybe six people, Nostr is an absolute value sink for anyone building anything right now. And love, passion, and motivation alone arenβt sustainable long-term. We need a mix of proper businesses (beyond L2 payment stuff) and FOSS culture here.
If Nostriches can buy raw milk, tallow soap, etc., they can also zap, say, 100k sats to the devs of the projects they use a few times a year. If enough people do this, Nostr becomes its own thing instead of just a BTC payment solution marketplace.
the community has already pushed away an absurd amount of competent people over the past decade. they're not coming.
Yea i might be one of the few crazies that donβt give a rats ass π
To the builders that don't give a rats ass! π»
"Fat zap them" - but who is gonna zap? Will you zap them regularly with decent amounts so they can pay the bills without fiat contracting job? I think this is why those grants are there
I'm zapping way, way, way more than the average Nostrich... Plus I have been maintaining a lot of Nostr software. Can't do it alone though. And Grants won't pay my bills either, not in the UK. You know what could? Like 10 USD a month * one third of the regulars here on Nostr. That could pay for the bills of a lot of devs and operators. You know how many people do this? Well, none is doing it for anything that I built or maintained so far.
You know how many people zap more on AI Generate memes and garbage copied from X than on Devs? A whole lot of people.
you propose we keep them around by zapping them $1k/day?
For a full-time senior developer in HCOL areas in the US (New York, San Francisco, etc.), yes, or at least close to it if youβd expect them to work 40+ hours a week, just like they would at Big Tech or Major Banks.
Nostr already has plenty of active npubs. How many active users do we have right now, around 30k? If 10k of them paid $10 a month, that would be enough to fund three full-time developers; say, Fiafjaf and a couple of core US-based devs. Alternatively, you could fund six people in Germany, twelve in South America, or even more across most of Asia. Or a mix of all that. You could also have part-time developers... lots of possibilities. And as Nostr grows the funding would increase.
Whatever the setup, I think donations should flow directly from plebs to devs . Not from BTC companies, not from billionaires, not from private equity and VC Funds. Otherwise, weβre essentially saying that Nostr (both the the protocol and the ecosystem) isnβt worth $10 a month to its users. And if thatβs the case, then honestly, there are already plenty of centralised, extractive social media solutions out there with a much better architecture than Nostr for the "ADS and User data extraction" use cases
Someone needs to add crowdfunding to
and we can start doing this tomorrow.
Put up a bounty for a feature in X open source client, assign it to the original author of the client, get the zaps, do the work. The client dev gets paid, the community gets their feature.

Catallax - A Protocol for Pseudonymous Contract Work Economies
Catallax is an open protocol that enables pseudonymous contract work economies. It runs over Nostr, Bitcoin and Cashu ecash for censorship-resistan...

Catallax - A Protocol for Pseudonymous Contract Work Economies
Catallax is an open protocol that enables pseudonymous contract work economies. It runs over Nostr, Bitcoin and Cashu ecash for censorship-resistan...
I am so here for the nostr civil war.
the evil powers that be can't stop us from building π
This reads like a small kid who lost at a basketball game π. Cope harder my dude
coping about what exactly
I don't know bro, you're the one crying
why do people keep using the word crying? I am not upset or physically crying. Maybe slightly disappointed?
Because when you can't make a solid argument, you just tear down your opponent.
time to go crazy. fuk it enable monero on damus. the cypherpunk beast inside is calling
jb55
monero is definitely the least scammy out of the privacy coins. zcash is a complete scam.
View quoted note →
canβt you just put your address in your profile? What would monero in damus look like?
homie thinks that perfect surveillance is a requirement for hard money
its unfortunately probably a precondition for mass adoption :/ at least we have lightning
people liked my old nostrudel fork because it just had a button that showed the address in a qr code, also had a "pay in wallet" because the bip21 auto-fills to send, then it's a plain tip button without the zap event and just opens the preferred wallet that accepts that URI scheme at the right place, things like this just get the address from bio "closer" to usage, without any advanced integration needed from the developer, which would work for btc onchain or alts too
but yeah not an actual integration, I'm remaking my client but will still use the simple idea, but this simple idea is enough for people to love it X users keep bugging platforms like odysee to do something like this and then it's an "integration", but to advance on a monero integration it could use payment IDs, or use the viewkey to generate subaddresses, then per event on send you know which event of yours got tipped, then from viewkey usage maybe a proper zap event could be created by using receipt proofs, etc, some people already experiment on this today
until people get comfortable trusting cryptographic proofs, I agree.
LN is good enough for now but its just not going to be the solution
Something better than lightning is coming. Something like what was built with Keet can't not have implications for transacting value
Holy shit, YOU made moStard?
Let me correct it for you
"There is a large monetary investment in centralized Nostr (primal) and centralized bitcoin (Custodial Shitcoin Cashu & Shitcoin Core)"
I already called out @DETERMINISTIC OPTIMISM π and @ODELL for funding Gay Calle today but I don't think they will ever respond back to me (including @jack) because they know that it's true.


Bitcoin_To_The_Oblivion
I don
is βgay calleβ necessary?
Calle is right about core, knots is dumb
Ok then maybe you both are dumb then...!!!
And have fun being coretard just like your friend "Gay Calle"
Absolutely.
It adds so much context for the people who can understand the meaning of FILTER but not for the people who don't understand the FILTER.


General bitcoin space suffers similar fate, its very centralized with several people influencing a lot more than ppl imagine through backchannels and string pulling.
The space is tiny and cross polination of organizations/events by the same individualas is huge, very easy get shadow banned
I didn't realize you had a beef with Cashu.
I have been openly critical about that project and its design choices and been treated like a red-headed piece of shit by a lot of people on here, particularly developers.
I have nothing against Primal, but I'm not interested in using their walled garden setup, so it is what it is.
i had no issues with him, until he started attacking me just because I wasn't 100% on board with cashu
i guess the "bitcoin for signal" and "bitcoin for imessage" irked me a lot as well. affinity scamming is such a bad look.
Yeah, he tends to do this.
And just to be honest, it's a red flag to me.
probably just defensive because he has to deal with the centralization criticism all the time. i can see how that would be annoying after awhile.
I do too, and I feel for him, but it's going to happen with that project. When a bunch of people are purists.
anything I can help with or clarify related to cashu? it's an open source project, we welcome pull requests.
Nope.
Tee hee. 

It isn't just cashu
the entire bitcoin space is paralyzed because everyone is terrified that if they do anything else
except for the reference-implementation HTLC-based blocksize-war approved thing
the big money won't follow them
and the big money is hostile anyway
we could have so much π’
At this point it's not just about money. Devs are scared of getting arrested. This is another reason the privacy focused Monero community is pulling ahead in the dev race
Regardless of who youβre calling out or frustrated by
The fact that you can have your opinion, free of fear (be that de-platforming or removal of funding), is the absolute key
About the only time I believe diversity is actually powerful as a metric is when it comes to opinions
Say what you want. Think what you want. Go for it
Youβre a pedophile


I once attended one of those βprestigiousβ corporate yacht events in Dubai. Letβs just say there were more suits than seagulls. π
But honestly, being out on the water itself was calmingβ¦ until someone started talking about Bitcoin nonstop. If you ever want to experience Dubai waters without the βinfluence peddling,β this page has some simple yacht options for corporate events (no crypto-talk guaranteed!): Keep being you!
Corporate Events Yacht Charter in Dubai - Sky Walker
Sky Walker offers corporate event yacht charter packages in Dubai with sound system, meeting space and catering, perfect for conducting client meet...
Whatβs the difference between Primal and Damus?
Good question...
Quite a bit but the main gripe people have is that Primal can be very X/twitter like. To put it simply.
Need to create a pros/cons list of these two clients, and any other client that has thrown their hat in the ring.
Youβre a pedophile


Iβd love to know more. Iβm a noob.
Primal fetch notes from other relay, your app read from primal.
Primal can choose what you read.
Other clients fetch directly from multiple relays.
We are looking for someone who can invest 45,000 US dollars in our company.
We are looking for an investor who can lend 45,000 US dollars to our company.
We are looking for an investor who can invest 45,000 US dollars in our company.
With this budget, we will produce our own uniquely designed furniture through our contracted manufacturers and offer them to the global market. By producing in bulk (wholesale), we will significantly reduce production costs and be able to sell high-quality, durable, and aesthetically pleasing furniture at affordable prices.
With the budget of 45,000 US dollars you will invest in our company, we will produce our own designed furniture and sell it in the global market.
With the money you lend, we will have the company we have agreed on produce quality furniture for a certain amount of money and sell it on the international market.
Since our furniture will be produced wholesale, we will provide a cost advantage and will be offered to customers at affordable prices.
In short, we will be able to sell quality, beautiful-looking, comfortable furniture to people at affordable prices.
Since the furniture we produce will be made of cheap and high-quality materials, people will want to buy it quickly.
You know that furniture is a type of profession that has been very profitable for years and will provide us with a large profit in a short time.
Thanks to our experience in advertising, we will expand into international markets and make quick profits.
Because our advertising network is strong, we will be able to acquire a customer base from many countries in a short time.
This means that within this project, your money will grow more than fivefold in a short period, providing you with a high and guaranteed profit.
πΌ Your Profit:
You will provide a loan of 45,000 US dollars to our company. We will invest these funds in our furniture business, grow the investment, and return a total of 250,000 US dollars to you by March 22, 2026.
You will invest 45,000 US dollars in our company. When 22.03.2026 comes, I will return your money as 250,000 US dollars.
In short, you will receive back the 45,000 US dollars you lent to our company as 250,000 US dollars, and we will give you back your money in an increased amount.
We will contact you on March 22, 2026, and refund your winnings of 250,000 US dollars.
To learn how to lend 45,000 US dollars to our company and to get detailed information about our educational project, send a message to my Telegram username below.
To learn how you can invest 45,000 US dollars in our company and how you can participate in our furniture project, send a message to my Telegram username below and I will give you detailed information.
To learn how you can multiply your money by investing 45,000 US dollars in our company and to get detailed information about our furniture project, send a message to my Telegram username below.
To learn how you can lend 45,000 US dollars to our company and increase your money by participating in our furniture project, send a message to my Telegram username below and all detailed information will be given to you.
Turn your capital into opportunity! Our company is seeking a 45,000 USD investment to expand our innovative furniture project. Join us and discover how your money can grow while supporting a global venture. For full details, message us on Telegram at the username below.
For detailed information and to learn how you can participate in our furniture project, send a message to my Telegram username below and I will give you detailed information.
My telegram username:
@adenholding
We are looking for someone who can invest 45,000 US dollars in our company.
We are looking for an investor who can lend 45,000 US dollars to our company.
We are looking for an investor who can invest 45,000 US dollars in our company.
With this budget, we will produce our own uniquely designed furniture through our contracted manufacturers and offer them to the global market. By producing in bulk (wholesale), we will significantly reduce production costs and be able to sell high-quality, durable, and aesthetically pleasing furniture at affordable prices.
With the budget of 45,000 US dollars you will invest in our company, we will produce our own designed furniture and sell it in the global market.
With the money you lend, we will have the company we have agreed on produce quality furniture for a certain amount of money and sell it on the international market.
Since our furniture will be produced wholesale, we will provide a cost advantage and will be offered to customers at affordable prices.
In short, we will be able to sell quality, beautiful-looking, comfortable furniture to people at affordable prices.
Since the furniture we produce will be made of cheap and high-quality materials, people will want to buy it quickly.
You know that furniture is a type of profession that has been very profitable for years and will provide us with a large profit in a short time.
Thanks to our experience in advertising, we will expand into international markets and make quick profits.
Because our advertising network is strong, we will be able to acquire a customer base from many countries in a short time.
This means that within this project, your money will grow more than fivefold in a short period, providing you with a high and guaranteed profit.
πΌ Your Profit:
You will provide a loan of 45,000 US dollars to our company. We will invest these funds in our furniture business, grow the investment, and return a total of 250,000 US dollars to you by March 22, 2026.
You will invest 45,000 US dollars in our company. When 22.03.2026 comes, I will return your money as 250,000 US dollars.
In short, you will receive back the 45,000 US dollars you lent to our company as 250,000 US dollars, and we will give you back your money in an increased amount.
We will contact you on March 22, 2026, and refund your winnings of 250,000 US dollars.
To learn how to lend 45,000 US dollars to our company and to get detailed information about our educational project, send a message to my Telegram username below.
To learn how you can invest 45,000 US dollars in our company and how you can participate in our furniture project, send a message to my Telegram username below and I will give you detailed information.
To learn how you can multiply your money by investing 45,000 US dollars in our company and to get detailed information about our furniture project, send a message to my Telegram username below.
To learn how you can lend 45,000 US dollars to our company and increase your money by participating in our furniture project, send a message to my Telegram username below and all detailed information will be given to you.
Turn your capital into opportunity! Our company is seeking a 45,000 USD investment to expand our innovative furniture project. Join us and discover how your money can grow while supporting a global venture. For full details, message us on Telegram at the username below.
For detailed information and to learn how you can participate in our furniture project, send a message to my Telegram username below and I will give you detailed information.
My telegram username:
@adenholding
Those 'prestigious events' are useless signaling events.
Just continue building good products!
We are looking for someone who can invest 45,000 US dollars in our company.
We are looking for an investor who can lend 45,000 US dollars to our company.
We are looking for an investor who can invest 45,000 US dollars in our company.
With this budget, we will produce our own uniquely designed furniture through our contracted manufacturers and offer them to the global market. By producing in bulk (wholesale), we will significantly reduce production costs and be able to sell high-quality, durable, and aesthetically pleasing furniture at affordable prices.
With the budget of 45,000 US dollars you will invest in our company, we will produce our own designed furniture and sell it in the global market.
With the money you lend, we will have the company we have agreed on produce quality furniture for a certain amount of money and sell it on the international market.
Since our furniture will be produced wholesale, we will provide a cost advantage and will be offered to customers at affordable prices.
In short, we will be able to sell quality, beautiful-looking, comfortable furniture to people at affordable prices.
Since the furniture we produce will be made of cheap and high-quality materials, people will want to buy it quickly.
You know that furniture is a type of profession that has been very profitable for years and will provide us with a large profit in a short time.
Thanks to our experience in advertising, we will expand into international markets and make quick profits.
Because our advertising network is strong, we will be able to acquire a customer base from many countries in a short time.
This means that within this project, your money will grow more than fivefold in a short period, providing you with a high and guaranteed profit.
πΌ Your Profit:
You will provide a loan of 45,000 US dollars to our company. We will invest these funds in our furniture business, grow the investment, and return a total of 250,000 US dollars to you by March 22, 2026.
You will invest 45,000 US dollars in our company. When 22.03.2026 comes, I will return your money as 250,000 US dollars.
In short, you will receive back the 45,000 US dollars you lent to our company as 250,000 US dollars, and we will give you back your money in an increased amount.
We will contact you on March 22, 2026, and refund your winnings of 250,000 US dollars.
To learn how to lend 45,000 US dollars to our company and to get detailed information about our educational project, send a message to my Telegram username below.
To learn how you can invest 45,000 US dollars in our company and how you can participate in our furniture project, send a message to my Telegram username below and I will give you detailed information.
To learn how you can multiply your money by investing 45,000 US dollars in our company and to get detailed information about our furniture project, send a message to my Telegram username below.
To learn how you can lend 45,000 US dollars to our company and increase your money by participating in our furniture project, send a message to my Telegram username below and all detailed information will be given to you.
Turn your capital into opportunity! Our company is seeking a 45,000 USD investment to expand our innovative furniture project. Join us and discover how your money can grow while supporting a global venture. For full details, message us on Telegram at the username below.
For detailed information and to learn how you can participate in our furniture project, send a message to my Telegram username below and I will give you detailed information.
My telegram username:
@adenholding
Come to Vienna on May 27th and May28th
More too share soon
Will after this post you have a new follower π
Capture thrives when itβs fuzzy. Make it measurable: publish an optβout friction score. Count chokepoints from keys to broadcast, selfβhost paths, and perβfeature off switches. We use this lens at Masters of The Lair. Would a public scorecard keep things honest?
Appreciate you saying this out loud.
I get the Primal criticism.
Cashu I'm less clear about. It's a protocol, not a specific product. Anyone can operate a mint, and indeed, as far as I can see, many do:
Yes, it is more centralized than Lightning, which is more centralized than L1 Bitcoin. But it has its use cases.
Mint Auditor
use cashu if you like cashu, i really donβt care. I personally donβt have any use for it and would rather focus on improving lightning tech