Bitcoin mining #trilemma ⛏
Bitcoin mining is known to be one of the most competitive industries on the planet, as working at the intersection between energy and money, two key items for the development of society, is a compelling task requiring being very strategic on the operational strategy to foster business sustainability 💹 over the long term.
Similar to blockchain’s trilemma ♻ which is based on #decentralization, #security and #scalability, where two conditions of the three can be fulfilled together but the last one ultimately resolves in not being optimised, bitcoin mining has its own trilemma.
Mining’s trilemma is based on availability of
(i) capital to deploy ,
(ii) mining machines, and
(iii) cheap source of energy.
These three conditions are key for strategic decision-making that miners need to navigate so to mine profitably and sustainably. Due to market dynamics, one condition of the three can never be optimised.
In mining, access to capital💲is a strong barrier to entry in the industry. Significant upfront costs need to be incurred by miners to get the necessary hardware, secure suitable sources of energy and cover the initial operational expenses. Once a site has been setup, capital is also required to remain competitive and being able to upgrade machines with more efficient ones, scale operations or weather market fluctuations due to changing bitcoin price or fees, the two revenue outputs from mining.
Once capital is secured, being able to acquire the right mining equipment does not come without issues. Mining machines 🖥 have complex manufacturing processes, require very specific microchips and their demand is tightly linked to bitcoin’s price – creating bottlenecks during bull runs and not finding many buyers during bear phases. Also, the obsolescence rate of mining equipment is very high and miners need to choose a balance between having more efficient machines and investing significant CapEx into them, or optimise their production by running older, less efficient machines, but at very low energy costs.
Energy is the main source of OpEx of miners🔌. Due to bitcoin fixed monetary policy and difficulty adjustment, access to the cheapest sources of energy can determine whether a miner is able to remain profitable after halving and other volatility events, or whether their OpEx are too high and lead to an unprofitable business. Finding cheap energy come with regulatory and geopolitical risks, as each country has its own specific environment concerning mining regulation, public perception of the activity and other social frictions.
Mining conditions are constantly changing within the trilemma due to market dynamics, investors’ sentiment, supply chain functioning, macroeconomics, and other factors. Bitcoin miners need to be dynamically adapting to different scenarios while growing their business, so to keep the Bitcoin network as safe and decentralized as possible.
H/t @Bob Burnett
